Electric Fireplace Or Space Heater - Which is Safer?

According to the National Fire Protection Assoc.fireplaces misused less than ordinary space
(NFPA) heating equipment was the second leadingheaters?
cause of home fires and home fire deaths.The answer to this lies in the overall size and
The heating equipment category includes centraldesign of the electric fireplace. The placement of
heating, fixed and portable space heaters andthe firebox in the middle of a 4 foot wide unit
wood stoves. Of these, fixed heaters (wallcreates a natural buffer zone on either side
mounted or freestanding propane heaters)between it and draperies, furniture or bedding that
accounted for 17% of the fires and 28% of themight be in the room.
civilian deaths.By keeping flammables away from the heater
Portable heaters (propane and electric) caused faryou will practically eliminate the number one cause
fewer fires, only 8% of the total, but accountedof space heater fires.
for 46% of the total deaths resulting fromA portable fireplace is also regarded as a beautiful
heating equipment fires.piece of furniture which makes it less likely that
So how can this be with increasingly stringentbags of clothing, boxes, etc. would be piled in
portable heater manufacturing safety standards?front of it - never mind blocking the heat source.
The best answer to this question comes fromThe perception that a fireplace, by virtue of its
Fire Chief Eric Chichester of Parkersburg, WV, asize, is more powerful than it really is probably
state which had 6 heater related deaths intempts fewer people to plug it into an overloaded
October: "The problem isn't really with the spaceextension cord. Plugging an electric fireplace into its
heater itself, but with misusing it and leaving itown wall socket all but eliminates another potential
unattended."fire hazard.
If misuse of the space heater and not the heaterFinally, the flame display, crackling fire sound
itself is the cause of fires, which type of heatereffect, and humming of the blower serve as a
would be prone to misuse more frequently; anconstant reminder the fireplace is running and
electric fireplace or space heater?makes it less likely it would be left on when the
Although far fewer electric fireplaces are sold inhouse is unoccupied.
North America than electric space heaters, closeRather than trying to pit the electric fireplace
tracking of the occurrences of space heater firesagainst the electric space heater, the real purpose
so far this season has yet to reveal an instanceof this article is to remind everyone that any
where an electric fireplace was a contributingspace heater can be a safe heater if you keep it
factor.at least 3' away from combustibles, don't use an
This suggests that people are less likely to misuseextension cord, and remember to turn it off
an electric fireplace and therefore the fireplace iswhen you go to bed and leave the house.
safer. But this begs the question; why are electric